Health Journalists Face Translation Challenge, Missouri Journalism Researchers Find

Majority of Health Journalists Lack Specialized Training, Nearly Half Not Familiar with Health Literacy

Amanda Hinnant Magazine Journalism Faculty María Len-Ríos Strategic Communication Faculty

Links

American Medical Association Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication Association of Health Care Journalists Health Communication Research Center Missouri Foundation for Health Missouri Health Literacy Enhancement Program University of Missouri U.S. Department of Education

By Emily Smith
MU News Bureau

Columbia, Mo. (Aug. 22, 2008) -- The media constantly inform the public of new health information, but many Americans have difficulty recognizing what they should, or should not do to improve their health. Missouri School of Journalism researchers conducted a national survey and found that the majority of health journalists have not had specialized training in health reporting and face challenges in communicating new medical science developments.

Assistant Professors Amanda Hinnant and María Len-Ríos surveyed 396 newspaper and magazine journalists and completed 35 in-depth interviews to offer insight into the role of journalists in reducing the negative effects of limited health literacy. Health literacy, as defined by the American Medical Association, is "the ability to obtain, process and understand basic health information and services needed to make appropriate health decisions and follow instructions for treatment."

"Almost half of the journalists reported they were not familiar with the concept of health literacy, but said that their readers' ability to understand health information was very important to consider when writing health stories," Hinnant said. "Increasing knowledge of health literacy could help journalists clarify medical information to readers."

Of the journalists surveyed, only 18 percent had specialized training in health reporting and only 6.4 percent reported that a majority of their readers change health behaviors based on the information they provide. The journalists had an average of 18 years of journalism experience and seven years experience as health journalists.

"Health journalists play an important role in helping people effectively manage their health," Len-Ríos said. "However, we found that many journalists find it difficult to explain health information to their readers, while maintaining the information's scientific credibility. They have to resist 'bogging down' the story with too much technical science data and 'dumbing down' the story with overly simplistic recommendations."

Journalists reported quoting medical experts, avoiding technical terms, and providing data and statistics as the three most important elements to making health information understandable. However, understanding numbers is a challenge for many people, Hinnant said. According to the U.S. Department of Education 2007 report, mathematics literacy is a serious problem in the United States. Only 39 percent of U.S. students are at or above the "proficient" level in grade eight and only 23 percent are at that level by grade 12. Mathematical knowledge is important to understand health information, Hinnant said.

"A large percentage of Americans are not health literate, which is related to significant health problems including medication errors, failing to seek treatment and an inability to understand directions about proper health behavior," Hinnant said. "The role of a health journalist includes translating medical information and acting as a liaison responsible for providing quality information. We need to actively find ways to improve health coverage and recognize the importance of the media's role in improving the public's quality of life."

According to the survey, journalists have complex views of what their readers can understand. A majority of journalists reported believing that their readers understand information from medical professionals, but are not proficient with scientific information and more prone to believe health myths. More than half of the respondents thought a majority of their readers used information simply to gain a better understanding of health issues or used it to communicate better with health professionals. The results suggest that newspaper journalists view their roles as information providers, while magazine journalists perceive themselves more as advocates for behavioral change.

Results from the study, "Tacit Understandings of Health Literacy: Interview and Survey Research with Health Journalists," were presented at the 2008 Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication Convention in Chicago. The paper received the Top Faculty Paper Award from the Science Communication Interest Group. The research was funded by the Missouri Foundation for Health and the Missouri Health Literacy Enhancement Priority Area Grant.

The Missouri School of Journalism is home to several health communication research initiatives, including the Association of Health Care Journalists, an independent membership organization dedicated to advancing public understanding of health care issues. Its mission is to improve the quality, accuracy and visibility of health care reporting, writing and editing. The Health Communication Research Center is a grant-funded center based at the School. Its primary mission is to foster interdisciplinary research to improve communication between the health care community and the public. The center capitalizes on the University of Missouri's strengths in health care outreach, education and prevention.

Related

Dec. 3, 2007: Missouri School of Journalism Shares Grant to Improve Missouri's Health Literacy The Missouri School of Journalism is part of a $726,784 grant from the Missouri Foundation for Health to build an infrastructure that will become an interactive and comprehensive health literacy resource throughout the state. The award was given in conjuction with the MU Center for Health Policy. The grant is part of $7.1 million in funding approved by the Missouri Foundation for Health to establish its Missouri Health Literacy Enhancement initiative. [More]

May 31, 2007: Foundations Support Launch of Midwest Health Journalism Program A consortium of six health foundations in Kansas and Missouri has pledged $724,739 to establish the Midwest Health Journalism Program, an annual fellowship program for reporters and editors from both states. The Association of Health Care Journalists, based at the Missouri School of Journalism, will conduct the training program through its Center for Excellence in Health Care Journalism. [More]

April 19, 2007: Three Missouri Students Receive Health Journalism Fellowships Master's student Traci Angel, senior Jamie Greber and junior Tara Ballenger were among 18 professionals and students from the state who received an expenses-paid trip to Health Journalism 2007, AHCJ's national conference. Headquartered at the Missouri School of Journalism, AHCJ is a nonprofit organization dedicated to advancing public understanding of health care issues. [More]

Jan. 31, 2007: Spirituality Plays Important Role in Breast Cancer Information Processing for African-American Women, Study Finds The American Cancer Society estimates that more than 178,000 women will be diagnosed with breast cancer in 2007. A new study from the Missouri School of Journalism has found that spirituality might play an important role in battling breast cancer through increased information sharing and use of early detection methods, particularly for African-American women. [More]

Feb. 27, 2006: Two Missouri Graduate Students Receive Health Journalism Fellowships Missouri School of Journalism graduate students Natalie Fieleke and Leslie Yingling are among the 20 recipients of the 2006 AHCJ-Missouri Health Journalism Fellowships. The Association of Health Care Journalists, which moved to the Missouri School of Journalism last summer, granted the fellowships to Fieleke and Yingling to support their attendance at Health Journalism 2006, the seventh national conference of AHCJ. [More]

March 28, 2005: Parents' Communication Styles Influence Children's Smoking Habits, Journalism Researchers Find The American Legacy Foundation recently reported that while the prevalence of smoking among high school students has decreased significantly in the past few years, this trend does not hold for middle school youth. Reports show that 10 percent of this age group has smoked at least one cigarette in the past 30 days. A new study by researchers at the University of Missouri-Columbia's Health Communication Research Center found that parents' communication styles significantly influence whether their teenager stops smoking. [More]